
Is there really no such thing as bad publicity? What Jensen Huang, robot ducks and a flying Tesla teach about your Google reviews
There is such a thing as bad publicity. The old saying "there's no such thing as bad publicity" is only half true: attention can make people aware of you, but it can't make them trust you. In the last month, Jensen Huang, then Nvidia's CEO, starred in two viral stories. One was a stage full of waddling robot ducks. The other was an affair he admitted on November 8. The scandal drew far more searches. It also came with a drop of nearly $200 billion in Nvidia's market value in two days. Four days after admitting the affair, Huang resigned. Look closer and the companies that came out ahead had one thing in common: they understood their customers.
So we measured both stories the way we'd judge any marketing push: by what it brings back, the same test we use to ask whether marketing pays for itself. We added Tesla's flying Roadster as a third case and looked at what the research says about why bad news spreads. This post makes two points. First, what virality really is and how to measure it. Second, why understanding your customer matters more than going viral, and more than any single mistake. Here's what we found, and what it means for your own Google reviews if you run a small or medium sized business.
What happened in each story?
The robot ducks. On October 21, Huang brought four Microduck robots on stage at Nvidia's GTC Berlin keynote. He asked them to walk, sit and somersault. When he told them to take a nap, three fell over at once and the fourth needed more persuading. The $399 robot comes from Pollen Robotics, part of Hugging Face, which Nvidia bought in September. The clip spread fast. Hugging Face co-founder Clem Delangue posted that preorders would pass 20,000 within about a day of the keynote. Preorders had opened on August 27, so that count includes buyers from before the demo.
The affair. On November 8, Huang told Nvidia employees he had been unfaithful to his wife. The New York Times identified the woman as Alice Huang (no relation). She is a former executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore data center company that buys Nvidia chips. American officials have linked her to Chinese intelligence; those claims are allegations, and the evidence hasn't been made public. Nvidia's board opened an independent investigation led by outside counsel. The board said it had no reason to believe national security or company secrets were compromised. On November 11, the New York Times reported a second relationship, with an Nvidia executive who reported to him. The next day, Nvidia announced that Huang had resigned as CEO and left the board, effective immediately. Chief financial officer Colette Kress became interim CEO.
The flying Roadster. On October 15, Tesla drove its new Roadster up a ramp in Texas, flipped it in midair and landed it past a row of cars. It came nine years after Tesla first showed the car. Memes took over X within minutes. Production isn't planned until 2028.
How do you measure how viral something is?
"Viral" gets used loosely. If you want to know whether attention helped or hurt, track four things, not one:
Reach, meaning how many people saw or searched for it. Track how much search demand grew, how fast videos about it gained views, and how many outlets covered it.
Sentiment. Whether people reacted with "love" or "angry," and whether the words around your name are positive or negative.
Business result. Sales, preorders, leads, bookings, or for a public company, its stock price.
Staying power. How fast interest fades once the story stops being new.
We pulled YouTube search estimates for all three stories on November 14, 2026. They are estimates from one platform, so read them as a comparison, not exact counts.
Robot ducks | Huang affair | Flying Roadster | |
|---|---|---|---|
Peak search term | "microduck": about 381,000 a month | "jensen huang": about 1.86 million a month, up 1,081%; "alice huang": about 230,000, up 9,881% | "flying tesla": about 483,000 a month |
Tone | Positive | Negative | Positive, with a lot of mocking |
Business result | 20,000+ preorders reported | Stock down 4.3% and 5.5% the first two days, then 4.3% the day he resigned | Stock up about 5% before the open, closed down 2.1% |
Staying power | Searches down about 64% from the prior period | Still climbing as of November 14, two days after he resigned | Searches down about 88% |
Did the robot ducks or the scandal get more attention?
The scandal, by a wide margin. Searches for Huang's name alone ran about five times higher than searches for the ducks. On top of that, "alice huang" went from almost nothing to roughly 230,000 searches in weeks.
The money moved the other way. The ducks gave a small team a sales spike and gave Nvidia a friendly robotics story. The affair hit the stock. On Monday, November 9, Nvidia fell as much as 8% during the day and closed down 4.3%, while the S&P 500 rose 2.4%. On Tuesday it fell another 5.5%. Over those two days, nearly $200 billion in value was erased. Then it got worse. On Thursday, November 12, the day Huang resigned, the stock fell more than 13% at the open before closing down 4.3%. On Friday it slipped another 2% and closed below $4 trillion in market value for the first time since July 2025.
Some of that drop wasn't about Huang. AI stocks were already sliding the week before, and Nvidia had lost about a quarter of its value in a month. Still, the gap with the wider market on Monday shows the scandal had a cost of its own.
That first-day drop is close to what research predicts. A study looked at 325 cases of executive misconduct. When the person was the CEO, companies lost about 4.1% of shareholder value, or $226 million on average (Cline, Walkling and Yore, Journal of Financial Economics, 2018). Investors read a leader's private conduct as a signal about how the company is run. Early that week, analysts at Citi framed the key questions as whether the probe finds something more serious and whether it limits sales.
What does the flying Roadster add?
It shows a third outcome: huge, mostly positive attention that changes nothing for the business.
The demo was everywhere. People joked that we got flying cars before Grand Theft Auto VI. Tesla shares rose about 5% before the market opened the next morning. Then they closed down 2.1% at $354.72. Analysts pointed out why. The Roadster is a low-volume halo car, built to lift the brand more than sales. Morningstar expects about 2,000 Roadster sales a year, against nearly 1.8 million total Tesla deliveries in 2026. A fun clip about a car that ships in 2028 doesn't change that math.
Searches for "flying tesla" have dropped about 88% since. That's the usual shape of a stunt: a tall spike and a short tail.
Why does bad news spread faster than good news?
Three lines of research explain most of what happened.
Strong feelings get shared. Jonah Berger and Katherine Milkman studied nearly 7,000 New York Times articles. Stories that sparked awe, anger or anxiety were more likely to be shared, and sad ones less (Journal of Marketing Research, 2012). The ducks gave people delight. The affair gave them shock, anger and worry, which are stronger fuel.
Negative words get clicked. A 2023 study tested more than 105,000 headlines on Upworthy. Each extra negative word raised the click rate by 2.3%, while each positive word lowered it by about 1% (Robertson and colleagues, Nature Human Behaviour). "Affair," "spy" and "investigation" are about as negative as headline words get.
Us-versus-them gets shared most. Researchers studied 2.7 million posts from news outlets and members of Congress. Each word about the other side raised the odds of a share by 67% (Rathje, Van Bavel and van der Linden, PNAS, 2021). The Huang story came with a U.S.-versus-China frame built in. That's why it spread to people who never think about chips.
So is bad publicity ever good?
The saying is old. It's often credited to the showman P.T. Barnum, and the phrase has been in print since at least 1916. The research gives it a partial pass.
Sometimes, for the unknown. One study looked at New York Times book reviews. A negative review raised sales by 45% for new or little-known authors, while it hurt sales for famous ones (Berger, Sorensen and Rasmussen, Marketing Science, 2010). For a name nobody knew, the review mostly made people aware the book existed. Weeks later, readers remembered the title and forgot the bad review.
Huang is the opposite case. Everyone already knew Nvidia, so the scandal added no awareness. It only added doubt. Within days, it cost him his job. And the scandal was about character, not taste. A bad review says "I didn't like this." A personal scandal makes people ask "can I trust them?"
That gives us a simple rule. Bad publicity can help when you're unknown and the criticism is about taste. It hurts when people already know you and the story is about honesty.
When has bad publicity actually helped a business?
It happens more than you'd think. Three cases stand out, plus one where it went the other way.
Tesla's broken window (2019). At the Cybertruck reveal, Tesla's design chief threw a steel ball at the "armor glass." It shattered. Then he tried the back window, and it shattered too. The internet mocked the truck for days, and Tesla's stock fell more than 6% the next day. Yet within a week, Musk said reservations had climbed from 146,000 to 250,000. Those were $100 refundable deposits, not sales. Still, the flop made a strange-looking truck famous overnight.
American Eagle's jeans ad (2025). The "Sydney Sweeney has great jeans" campaign set off a heated online debate. The company didn't pull the ads or put out statements. Its CEO told staff to stay calm and not comment, while a small team watched social media and an outside firm polled customers. Six weeks in, the brand reported 700,000 new customers, and its shares jumped 34% in a day. One caution: same-store sales still slipped 1% that quarter, so buzz didn't fix everything.
The unknown authors. As the book review study showed, a bad review gave first-time authors a 45% sales lift because it was often the first time anyone heard of them.
Where it backfired: Bud Light (2023). A promotion with a transgender influencer drew a boycott, largely from the brand's own regular drinkers. In the four weeks ending June 3, Bud Light sales fell 24.6% from a year earlier and it lost its spot as America's top-selling beer. A year later it had slipped to third.
Why did it help some and hurt others?
Starting from zero exposure is one reason, but it isn't the only one. Put the cases side by side and four things decide it:
How known you were. Unknown authors gained awareness. Nvidia couldn't, because everyone already knew it.
Who got angry. American Eagle's critics were mostly people who weren't buying its jeans anyway. Bud Light's critics were its core buyers.
What the story was about. A cracked window or a cheeky ad is about taste or a goof. An affair tied to a national security probe is about trust.
Whether there was something to buy right now. Cybertruck fans could put down $100 that night. American Eagle had jeans on the shelf. The Roadster won't ship until 2028, so the buzz had nowhere to go.
Tesla is a useful test here. Its Cybertruck flop came with a cheap, instant way to act. Its Roadster stunt didn't. Same company, same kind of viral moment, two very different results.
How much do PR teams change how a brand is seen?
Most large companies keep a public relations team for exactly this. Their job in a crisis is to decide how fast to respond, what to admit and who should speak. The research says those choices matter, but they can't erase the facts.
A study of 223 company crises found that apologizing helps the stock when the company is at fault, and hurts when it isn't (Racine, Wilson and Wynes, Journal of Business Ethics, 2018). Getting the match wrong in either direction cost shareholders money. Another study of 128 celebrity endorser scandals found that admitting the problem and apologizing was the most helpful response (Management Science). But a 2023 study of apologies for chemical disasters found no significant stock reaction on average. A response can soften a hit. It rarely reverses one.
What did each company's response do?
You can see all of this in the cases above:
Nvidia moved fast. The board announced an independent investigation and Huang apologized that weekend. The stock still fell. Investors were waiting on facts no statement could supply. Three days later, a second relationship surfaced. The next day, Huang resigned.
Bud Light was slow and vague. It took the CEO almost two weeks to put out a statement, and critics called it an attempt to please everyone that achieved nothing. It angered people on both sides.
American Eagle chose silence on purpose, but it wasn't passive. It watched the conversation, asked its customers what they thought and kept selling.
Tesla has run without a U.S. press team since it dissolved its PR department in 2020. Musk's own posts do the talking. That works for spectacle. It leaves the company with no one to steady the story when news turns bad.
The pattern is simple. PR shapes how people feel about the facts. It can't change the facts themselves.
Why do Google reviews matter so much?
You'll probably never face a scandal like Nvidia's. But you face a small version of it every week. Every Google review is publicity you don't control, and it sits right next to your name when people search for what you do.
Reviews also affect whether people find you at all. Google says review count and review score factor into local search ranking. So your reviews cover all four measures from earlier: reach (where you rank), sentiment (your stars), business results (calls and visits) and staying power (old reviews stay up for years).
They move money, too. A Harvard Business School study found that a one-star increase on Yelp led to a 5% to 9% increase in revenue for independent restaurants (Luca, 2011). Chains saw no such effect, because people already knew them. It's the same pattern as the book reviews: the less known you are, the more each review counts.
How you respond matters as well. When hotels started replying to their TripAdvisor reviews, they got 12% more reviews and their ratings rose 0.12 stars on average (Proserpio and Zervas, Marketing Science, 2017). Unhappy guests became less likely to post short, unfair complaints once they knew someone was reading.
That's this whole post in miniature. Know your customers, measure more than likes, and answer like someone who's paying attention.
What should a small or medium sized business take from this?
Most small businesses don't have Nvidia's problem. Their problem is the robot ducks' problem: getting noticed at all. Start with the lesson that runs through every case: know who your buyers are and what they value before you chase attention or react to a mistake. Here's how to use these lessons in your own viral marketing without gambling your brand reputation on outrage.
Aim for awe, not anger. The ducks worked because they were surprising and delightful. A behind-the-scenes clip of a hard job done well, a before-and-after, or a customer's real result can create that same high-energy feeling.
Measure all four things. Next time a post takes off, check more than views. Did calls, form fills or bookings go up that week? Were the comments warm or hostile? Did interest last past three days?
You are your own PR department. Most small businesses don't have a communications team, so the owner is it. The research is clear that scandals about honesty cost the most, and that the response has to fit the fault. If you made the mistake, say so and fix it. If you didn't, explain calmly. Either way, answer within a day. That's the short answer to how to respond to negative reviews: fast, calm and matched to the fault. A slow reply to an angry review can do more damage than a quiet month.
Don't chase controversy. Picking a fight online can spike reach, and it can bring the wrong kind of attention. If people already know you, it's more likely to cost you than help you.
What can you check today?
Here's a quick check you can run today. Search your business name and read the first page of results and your newest five reviews. Write down how many are positive, negative or neutral. That's your sentiment baseline, and it takes about 15 minutes.
Each week you don't track this, a bad review or an unanswered complaint can sit at the top of your results, shaping what new customers think before they ever call. If you want to know how many people find you, see you and choose you, it helps to look at all four measures together. Tracking them every week, answering every review within a day and turning what customers say into better listings and pages takes real time. That steady reputation management is a big part of what a digital marketing partner does for a small business. It's also how search visibility works: being found is only step one.
Why understanding your customer matters more than going viral
One thing predicted every outcome better than the size of the buzz or the size of the mistake: whether the company understood its customers.
American Eagle did. It polled its customers in the middle of the storm and kept selling to them. The loudest critics weren't the people buying its jeans.
Bud Light didn't. The promotion itself was small, not a big ad campaign. Misreading its own core drinkers, then answering with a statement aimed at everyone, is what made it expensive.
Cybertruck fans wanted something bold and strange, so a shattered window barely mattered to them. The Roadster gave those same fans nothing to buy, so the buzz faded.
For Nvidia in a crisis, the audience that counts isn't people scrolling memes. It's investors, governments and the companies that buy its chips. They care about trust and security, which is exactly what the scandal touched. Four days after his first apology, Nvidia had an interim CEO.
Mistakes work the same way. A goof your customers can laugh off is a story. A goof that hits what they value most is a crisis. You can only tell which is which if you know them.
So yes, there is such a thing as bad publicity. Virality tells you how far a story traveled. Your customers decide whether it helped.
Artenon is a New York based digital marketing agency for small and medium sized businesses. If you want to see how people find, see and talk about your business, start with a free Custom Digital Presence Review, built around your business. Schedule your free review.